realstupidshit.com

America's dumbest corner of the internet

Search | Submit a tip
Gas Pump Scam Watch

Virginia police are warning drivers about the gas pump screw scam, where thieves disable pumps so they can drain your account later, because apparently stealing fuel now requires mechanical engineering

The Timberville Police Department warned of a new scam where criminals place a screw or object in a fuel pump handle cradle to keep the pump active after you leave, allowing them to use your payment method.

June 11, 2026 • Real Stupid Shit Desk

What Happened

The Timberville Police Department in Virginia issued a warning on social media about a scam that would be funny if it wasn't basically theft. Here's how it works:

  1. A scammer places a screw, nail, or similar object into the fuel pump handle cradle
  2. You come along and use the pump normally, not noticing the object
  3. The object prevents the pump from shutting off properly after you remove the nozzle
  4. The pump stays "active" on your payment method (credit or debit card)
  5. The scammer returns and fills up their own vehicle using your still-active pump and your payment information
  6. You drive away thinking you just bought $40 in gas. You actually bought $40 + whatever they stole

According to FOX, the police department is recommending drivers check the pump before and after refueling. If something looks off or tampered with, don't use it and notify the attendant immediately.

The Actual Problem

What makes this scam particularly annoying is that it's low-tech but effective. No hacking, no phishing, no elaborate social engineering — just a screw and the assumption that most people don't examine their gas pump before using it.

The police also recommend checking that the pump reads $0.00 before you start and making sure the transaction completely ends before driving off. You should also check your credit card or debit card statements regularly to catch fraudulent charges early.

The Prevention Angle

This is one of those scams where prevention is dead simple: pay attention. Spend five seconds looking at the pump. Make sure the nozzle actually shuts off. Watch your card statements. These are not radical precautions.

The Timberville Police Department put it plainly: "Staying alert and reporting suspicious activity can help protect you and others from becoming victims of this scam."

And if you do suspect you've been hit, contact your bank immediately to dispute charges and potentially freeze or replace your card.

Sources

FOX: 'Screw scam' spurs new fears for drivers when filling their tanks

Timberville Police Department Facebook Warning

← Back to Scam Watch